CompHub: Cut the crap. Play the good maps. DUEL MAPS NEEDED

[Balrog]

So I'm going to be working on another hub map once I'm done fixing HUB-MM8BDM. Unlike that mod, this will actually be a DUEL32 replacement. (Well, technically the map will be a skin of DUEL16, but I digress.) However, to do that, I'll need suggestions for maps to include - and that's where you come in.

Current map list:

(click to show/hide)

Tomahawk Man (MM6TOM) by CutmanMike
 Skull Man (MM4SKU) by CutmanMike
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 EMPTY
 Cut Man (MM1CUT) by CutmanMike

I ask the competitive-oriented members of this community to pick what they think are the best maps for Duel. They can be from the main game or custom maps, but keep in mind that I would like a good balance between the two.

[Hallan Parva]

Tomahawk Man?
You know, the one filled with Silver Tomahawk?
A GOOD MAP!?

BAHAHAHAHAHA no.


I'd like to suggest Fire Man from vanilla, though.

[Korby]

I've always been fond of MM3HAR and MM1DW1, myself.

[Magnet Dood]

I've always found Charge Man as my go-to map for duels. It's a decent size for the most part.

[? Manibogi ?]

I'd love to see color-coded castle in this.

[TheDoc]

I'd choose Flashman as my duel map because it's a small open area.

[Orange juice :l]

MM3DW1.

But honestly, I don't think we need a Hub for ONLY duel maps. Duel players would probably stick with the map with more options.

[Balrog]

Well, the idea is so that you can have a selection of the best stock and custom maps in one mod for easy access and setup.

Great suggestions, guys! Keep 'em coming!

[Knux]

Wood Man is a very nice choice for Duels. Small with a decent amount of weapons.

[Tesseractal]

MM3DW1.

But honestly, I don't think we need a Hub for ONLY duel maps. Duel players would probably stick with the map with more options.

You say that, but duelists like me don't like playing on MM7SPR every one in five maps. Or MM5GYR, or other joke maps. Given the rarity of server hosts editing map rotations at all, I find this a significant contribution to the duel scene. (That is, of course, wouldit catch on.)

Here's 16 stock maps I would consider:

(click to show/hide)

MM1FIR
MM2WOO
MM2FLA
MM3GEM
MM3HAR
MM3DW1

MM4DRI
MM4SKU
MM4BRI
MM4DC1
MM5STO
MM5NAP

MM6TOM
MM6YAM
MM6FLA
MM1DW1 (Thanks, Korby! I almost forgot this.)

MM7 maps purposely omitted.

As for custom maps, the majority of them are too large. (With the exception of "Duel" maps, which, ironically, are far too small for even duel. AMP01, XDUEL01 being great failures in that regard.) AMP02, IDM10 are fine for duel. Duel servers rarely host custom maps, so expect the overall familiarity with them to be low. A couple of other AMP / IX maps would likely fit although I haven't looked at them in long enough to say which ones specifically.

[TheDoc]

Hmmmm....CSCM01 seems like a good custom duel map to me.

[Orange juice :l]

Sure, but why not have it there anyways? It's not like it'll be picked randomly if it's in a hub. If you remove it, you're just limiting the mod.

Anyways, most of the AMP maps are pretty good for duel, especially 1.