Obligatory Mafia II: Generic Mafia [OVER]

[*Alice]

JDude is doing something that would be hilariously idiotic for a Mafia member.

I think JDude's a townie and really awful at being that.

Can't think of anything else.

[Max]

+vote JDude because his reasoning sounds like a mafia member trying wayyyy too hard to start a bandwagon and shift attention from them

[Knux]

Just jumping in to mention that, speaking of bandwagons and shifting attention away from others, Max and Alice sure didn't waste time in feeding the ColdFusion wagon (even before JDude posted and even if the time frame between the posts was kinda small.) I'm bringing both up specifically because it's ironic that they seem hostile and the nature of their posts seems attention shifting themselves. Now, I'm not by any means defending JDude or his logic. I voted for Ivory because I thought his reasoning for voting Shade Guy was kinda dumb, since roles can't always be the same across mafia games.

Then again, trying to incriminate people for stuff they most likely didn't know (since it was the first day) is probably even dumber, so I'm going to switch my vote to JDude for the moment and see what becomes of it all.

[Rozark]

You do realize that the coldfusion wagon on the first day is tradition and trying to ruin it is bad for fun/shouldn't be taken seriously.

[Jdude330]

I have a couple more reasons to believe Ivory is innocent, but for now I'll keep them to myself.

I think that this give me a concept to trust you. I SHOULD self-preserve, but I'll abstain instead.
But, please, hear me out. This is my first time playing mafia over the internet. I'm used to playing with people, and thus my reasoning is a bit different. I'm infamous for my Far-off claims. plus, It's the second day, and I regret voting now. Ivory seemed a bit strange to me, but I guess Knux's claim kind of had me vote prematurely. I was just playing around with the ColdFusion bandwagon, and I was open to change if I saw some really incriminating evidence. I don't think any of you are mafia, either. Besides, how does reasoning bad make me mafia. I could be mafia, but I could have an ability to scan with, or just be very mediocre at mafia. hint: it's the latter
EDIT: We need to be careful with our votes.  one of the people can only be lynched during the day, and killing them would be bad.
EDIT 2: I didn't know Shade guy was ganondorf, as I really didn't read that one.

[SmashTheEchidna]

But, please, hear me out. This is my first time playing mafia over the internet. I'm used to playing with people, and thus my reasoning is a bit different.

This is my first time playing Mafia ever. But to be fair, I've been watching them ever since Smashbro's mafia, so I kinda know how things work, more or less.

I think I agree with what Alice said though, and am willing to bet you aren't Mafia either.
but if you end up lynching me in my sleep, my ghost will haunt you forever. >:C

[MasterXman]

Jdude330: 3
Ivory: 1

EVERYONE > Jdude330

Jdude330 was Ludger Kresnik (from Tales of Xillia 2). He was a townie and had no abilities.

??? > SmashBroPlusB

SmashBroPlusB was a Ninja. He was an independent person who was invincible during night phases.

Generic townie Korby has been revived by a mysterious power!

NIGHT II

Mafia and people who have night abilities, go do things.

[SmashTheEchidna]

So there's a mysterious person who can murder people during the day like the mafia can at night? Hoo boy.

[Max]

lol quick let's shove korby in their face so he can die and kill someone else

do lots of townies not have abilities? that's kinda weird since a lot of the abilities we did see were pretty crazy

[Jdude330]

Crap. welp, I'll get better.

[<geminibro>]

Ah shucks, i can't vote, and plus, i went without computer with the first day and night, and the second day. Oh well.

[MasterXman]

Things happened.

??? > Galactan

Galactan was Skullman. He was  a townie who was invincible during day phases.

Max has lost half of her HP.

Someone currently has invul right now and can't die.

DAY III

There be votin' goin' on right now.

[<geminibro>]

Going with gut feelings and voting for Beed28.

[SmashTheEchidna]

Skull Man sounds more like the person who would be invincible during the night phases, though. :T

Oh well. RIP Galactan. I knew you were innocent too, man.
I just wish I knew who was evil.

+Abstain because still no incriminating leads.

[Knux]

The death of JDude, whom I suspected to be innocent regardless of voting for him, made me suspect *Alice and Max of being mafia all the more. Since I can't vote for both of them, I'm going to vote for *Alice because she seemed very hostile even if she didn't vote.

I also encourage all town who aren't getting involved in the game to do so before mafia wipes everything out by themselves during night phases.